Recreational Red Abalone Management Strategies Integration
The California Ocean Protection Council (OPC) uses partnerships, policy and funding to advance science-based solutions to safeguard marine life, habitats and livelihoods in California. OPC has partnered with Tribes and Tribal communities, California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW), California Fish and Game Commission (FGC), The Nature Conservancy (TNC), and representatives from the recreational red abalone fishing community to support integration of proposed recreational red abalone management strategies.
Following a scientific peer review of two management strategies under consideration for the Recreational Red Abalone Fishery Management Plan (FMP) in 2018, the FGC made the following recommendations at its December 2018 meeting: (1) address peer review recommendations to integrate the two proposed management strategies; (2) develop a de minimis (i.e., managed/restricted access) fishery option; and (3) develop a more comprehensive process and timeline to engage and consult with stakeholders.
To accomplish this, a working meeting is being held to establish a Project Team and initiate its charge. The Project Team is open to all interested members of the public, including Tribes and Tribal communities, members of the abalone fishing community, scientists, resource managers, and others. Over the next six months, the Project Team will provide advice and guidance intended to assist CDFW and FGC as they consider final options for a Recreational Red Abalone FMP for the North Coast. Please see below for details on upcoming Project Team in-person meetings and/or webinars, as well as information from previous Project Team meetings.
Administrative Team Report
The final Administrative Team report (April 17, 2020) is available here.
The April 17, 2020 report incorporates feedback from the Fish and Game Commission Marine Resources Committee (MRC) based on discussion during the March 17, 2020 MRC meeting.
The draft Administrative Team report (February 14, 2020) is available here.
The Administrative Team, consisting of a Tribal representative, OPC, CDFW, FGC, TNC, and fishing industry representatives, developed a report to respond to the December 2018 Fish and Game Commission motion and to summarize the management strategy integration process. The report is intended to capture and summarize Project Team discussions and guidance from May 2019-December 2019, including guidance related to the Management Strategy Evaluation (MSE) results, the Exceptional Circumstances Strawman proposal, De Minimis Strawman proposal, etc.
Project Team Meetings
Tribes and Tribal communities, stakeholders, and interested members of the public are invited to participate in the sixth and final of a series of Project Team meetings to guide the development of the Recreational Red Abalone Fishery Management Plan (FMP) for the North Coast.
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team Meeting #6: Develop & Confirm Guidance for the Northern California Recreational Red Abalone Management Strategy: December 19, 2019: Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
December 19, 2019 Key Meeting Highlights
High-Priority Meeting Materials:
- Agenda
- Next steps for modelers from November 21, 2019 Project Team meeting
- High-level Summary of Updated Management Strategy (December 2019 version)
- Updated De Minimis Strawman Proposal (December 2019 version)
- Updated Exceptional Circumstances Strawman Proposal (December 2019 version)
- Draft Technical Report on Management Strategy Evaluation (December 2019 version)
Background Materials:
- November 21, 2019 Meeting Highlights
- Updated Project Team Work Plan
- Data Stream Comparison Table (August 2019 version)
- Draft Technical Report on Management Strategy Evaluation- November 22, 2019
- Updated Glossary of Key Terms (December 2019 version)
- Project Team Proposals for De Minimis Fishery (as received, listed below under “Project Team Proposals)
Presentations:
- Project Team Updates Since November 21 Meeting
- Review and Discuss Management Strategy Evaluation Results
- Updated De Minimis Strawman Proposal
- Next Steps for Red Abalone FMP Management Strategy Integration
Webinar Recording: RedAbaloneFMP_ProjectTeam_12192019.mp3 (158 MB)
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team Meeting #5: Review Management Strategy Evaluation Results & Develop Recommendations for Draft De Minimis Fishery: November 21, 2019: Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
High-Priority Meeting Materials
- Agenda (here)
- Exceptional Circumstances Strawman Proposal (here)
- High-level Summary of Results from the Two-zone Management Strategy Evaluation (here)
- Revised Strawman De Minimis Fishery Proposal (here)
Background Materials
- Updated Project Team work plan (here)
- Glossary of key terms (here)
- Next steps for modelers from August 27/September 19, 2019 Project Team meeting (here)
- De minimis fishery ideas and concepts received from the public (listed under “Project Team Proposals” below)
PowerPoint Presentations + Webinar: September 19, 2019 Project Team Meeting:
- Project Team Updates since September 19
- Interpreting Management Strategy Evaluation Results
- Review and Discuss Management Strategy Evaluation Results
- De Minimis Fishery Draft Strawman Proposal
- Exceptional Circumstances Draft Proposal
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team: Meeting #4: Revised Management Strategy & Continued Discussion on De Minimis Fishery: September 19, 2019: Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
- September 19, 2019 Project Team Meeting Agenda (webinar)
- Updated, High-level Summary of Revised Draft Management Strategy
- Technical Report on Revised Draft Management Strategy (updated September 17, 2019)
- Updated, Project Team work plan
- Updated, Glossary of Key Terms
- Updated, Proposed Next Steps for Modelers
- Data Stream Comparison Table (August 2019 version)
PowerPoint Presentations + Webinar: September 19, 2019 Project Team Meeting:
- Project Team Updates Since August 27, 2019
- Refining the Draft Management Strategy
- Discussing the De Minimis Fishery
- Webinar Recording
September 19, 2019, Project Team Meeting: Key Themes Summary
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team: Meeting #3: Discussion of Draft Management Strategies: Tuesday, August 27, 2019: Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
High-Priority Meeting Materials
- August 27, 2019 Project Team Meeting Agenda (in-person meeting in Santa Rosa, CA)
- High-level summary of draft management strategy
- Updated, data stream comparison table
- Updated, proposed next steps for modelers
Background Materials
- Draft de minimis fishery proposals (here)
- Key Themes Summary from July 18 Project Team meeting (webinar) (here)
- Updated, Project Team work plan (here)
- De minimis fishery ideas and concepts received from the public (listed under “Project Team Proposals” below)
PowerPoint Presentations
- Updates Since July 18 Project Team Meeting
- An Overview of Fishery Management Strategies
- Review and Consideration of Draft Management Strategies
August 27, 2019 Project Team Meeting: Key Themes Summary
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team: Meeting (Webinar) #2: Update on Work Plan and Discussion of Data Streams and De Minimis Fishery Design Options: July 18, 2019 Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
- July 18, 2019 Project Team Meeting Agenda (webinar)
- Draft de minimis fishery proposals
- Draft datastream comparison table
- Updated Project Team Work Plan
- Glossary of key terms
- Next steps for modelers from May 22, 2019 Project Team meeting
- De minimis fishery ideas and concepts received from the public (please see below “Project Team Proposals” section)
- North Central Coast Baseline Surveys of Kelp Forest Ecosystems: A report prepared for Sea Grant. Mark Carr, Emily Saarman, Dan Malone: University of California Santa Cruz. November 1, 2013 (here)
- Project Team Updates since May 22 from the Modelers (PowerPoint Presentation)
- Potential Data Streams for Red Abalone Fishery Management (PowerPoint Presentation)
- De Minimis Fishery Concept (PowerPoint Presentation)
- Webinar Recording
July 18, 2019 Project Team Meeting: Key Themes Summary
Recreational Red Abalone FMP Project Team Meeting #1: Review and Discuss Management Strategies and Brainstorm on Managed/Restricted Access Fishery Options: May 22, 2019 Meeting Agenda + Meeting Materials:
- May 22, 2019 Project Team Meeting Agenda (In-person meeting in Santa Rosa, CA)
- Project Team Draft Work Plan
- Project Team Charter (Updated June 2019)
- Presentations from Project Team Meeting (May 22, 2019)
- Red Abalone Fishery Management Plan (FMP) Development Process (CDFW)
- Peer Review Summary
- Red Abalone FMP Management Strategy Integration Process Overview (Admin Team)
- Management Strategies: Intro to Integration Tools & Guidance on Next Steps
- Restricted Access Fishery Possibilities (CDFW)
- Worksheet from Breakout Group Discussions during Project Team Meeting (May 22, 2019)
- California Ocean Science Trust Recreational Red Abalone Fishery Peer Review webpage (here)
- Peer review report (here)
- Recommendations from December 2018 Fish and Game Commission meeting (here)
- CDFW Red Abalone FMP webpage
- Abalone Recovery and Management Plan (ARMP) (CDFW)
May 22, 2019 Project Team Meeting: Key Themes Summary
Project Team Meetings + Webinars: Draft Schedule
- May 22, 2019 (in-person in Santa Rosa)
- July 18, 2019 (webinar)
- August 27, 2019 (in-person in Santa Rosa)
- September 19, 2019 (webinar)
- November 21, 2019 (in-person in Santa Rosa)
- December 19, 2019 (webinar)
The FGC Marine Resources Committee is planning to meet on November 5, 2019, and the FGC is planning to meet on December 11-12, 2019.
Project Team Proposals
Proposals and ideas related to the red abalone FMP process for the Project Team’s consideration, including proposals for a de minimis/restricted/managed access fishery, etc. All proposals must be received no later than the July 2019 Project Team meeting to be considered by the Project Team. Please submit proposals to hello@strategicearth.com. All proposals will be made publicly available.
Proposals received from Project Team members and interested members of the public:
- Jack Likins- Submitted May 22, 2019 Project Team meeting
- Steven Rebuck- Submitted May 22, 2019 Project Team meeting
- Brandi Easter- Submitted May 22, 2019 Project Team meeting
- Don Thompson- Submitted May 22, 2019 Project Team meeting
- Steven Rebuck- Submitted June 12, 2019
- Edward Schulze- Submitted June 19, 2019
- Ken Morrill- Submitted June 26, 2019
- Brandi Easter – Submitted July 10, 2019
- Doug Jung- Submitted August 11, 2019
- Steve Rebuck- Submitted August 12, 2019
- Scott Taylor – Submitted September 2019
- Jack Likins – Submitted September 24, 2019
- Jan Freiwald – Submitted October 3, 2019
- Ken Morrill – Submitted October 9, 2019
- Petition for New Abalone Management Zone – Submitted October 18, 2019
- Ken Morrill – Submitted November 18, 2019
- Ed Schulze – Submitted November 19, 2019
- Steven Rebuck – Submitted November 29, 2019
- Don Thompson – Submitted December 18, 2019
Additional Resources
- Project Team Charter (Updated June 2019)
- Administrative Team Charter (Updated October 2019)
- OPC Scientific Peer Review project webpage
- California Ocean Science Trust Recreational Red Abalone Fishery Peer Review webpage (here)
- Peer review report (here)
- Recommendations from December 2018 Fish and Game Commission meeting (here)
- Abalone Recovery and Management Plan (CDFW)
- For more information, please visit the CDFW Red Abalone FMP webpage
OPC & Strategic Earth Grant Agreement: Red Abalone Proposed Management Strategies Integration, Project Team
Support
To support this process, OPC entered into a grant agreement with Strategic Earth to provide neutral facilitation support of the Project Team process to inform integration of the red abalone management strategies. Strategic Earth will develop meeting summaries and other related deliverables per the grant agreement, which will be posted publicly on this OPC red abalone project webpage. Supporting information regarding approval of this grant agreement may be found in the Executive Director’s report (page 4 and page 11) for the May 23, 2019, OPC meeting.
Timeline: May 2019 – March 2020
Grant Amount: Up to $79,081
Grantee: Strategic Earth